the shop set ups on these guitars is IME invariably terrible Got a dynarette guitar cushion. I'm using Vintage T in my esquire. I know I will always have the guitar that I'm installing it in. The dimarzio 36th PAF will be the most versatile of the ones you listed. I ended up liking the feel and response of the Lollar a bit more although the low wind. but is hardly "boutique" is the Seymour Duncan SPB-1. Found both uninspiring. Seymour Duncan SH-1N 59 Model Humbucker for Neck - Single Conductor (Black) SEY-1200217. The 57 Classic Plus is the perfect companion for the 57 Classic, and provides a beautiful PAF style fat tone with a vintage flavor for playing blues, jazz, and rock in the vein of the legendary Steve Howe of Yes. Powered by Invision Community. Members; guitarcapo. I've had some nice e-mail responses to pickup questions I've had from Lollar recently. The Lollar Imperial humbucker pickups are made with Alnico 2 magnets for the neck position and Alnico 5 magnets for the bridge position. The PRRI has the same 5751 in V2 and I'm awaiting the arrival of a Weber 10F150 to replace the stock speaker with. The Gear Page is the leading online community and marketplace for guitars, amps, pedals, effects and associated gear. It's just twangy enough, dry, stripped down and has a decidedly Duncan tone. Had both, never in the same guitar. DC: Neck 7.6K, Bridge 8.4K Low Wind Imperial Humbucker i've tried one snakehead and totally felt for it but it was too expensive for my jazz youngster wallet. 6" or 8"? . I'm not saying the Fralins or Lollars are worse or even, I'm saying it all depends on what the person wants. 1 close mic only. I had them in my 535 when I got it and they sounded okay. I use a GT8 model, but the basics are all the same. I can't comment on your topic directly - I have never played Imperials - I just wanted to chime in with my 2c on Duncan '59s.there are a lot of Duncan haters out there, but I'll tell you - I really like the Duncan '59s. I use a GT8 model, but the basics are all the same. I read something online recently when searching, and someone described the Lollar, and Fralin pickups as being in a different league over the Seymour Duncan, DiMarzio pickups, etc. , has a solid spruce top instead of the usual maple. Can't find the one you want? Just some thoughts before you start buying more pickups. Pickups loaded into the same guitar, with the same amp on the same exact settings. Seymour Duncan SH-4 JB Model Humbucker for Bridge (Zebra) SEY-1200273. Ask the guy I sold a Les Paul Studio which had a set of Fralin P92 in itI offered to switch out the pickups for about 5 or 6 options at the time (including stock Gibson) at no cost and there was no way those pickups were coming out of that guitar. That's what I had in there before, a Dimarzio 36th with an A4 in the neck. This increases the output, making it ideal to use in the bridge position. Another indicator perhapswith the money that Lollars and Fralins command, there would be WAY more for sale if there were a well-known equal that was cheaper. So when he did his signature deal with Gibson, he logically had them load APH's into the prototypes. Recently I purchased a Tele Hot Rod Telebration in eBay which has a Duncan 59 stock in the neck , thought of changing it to an Imperial as soon as it arrived . Guitar "feel". However, what justifies the price difference of a set of Lollar pickups, or Fralins over something from Seymour Duncan or DiMarzio? They are not bright at all and are very balanced and articulate. Guitar, to some extent, feels your desirable sound and provides that with efficiency. Lollar Imperials are amazing, and the Low Wind set has the most presence and sparkle. You can get a dark but present jazz tone, a sweet blues tone, and a round classic rock tone. Most Successful Signature Guitar Of All Time? When used together in the bridge and neck position, they achieve an open and slightly hollow sound reminiscent of two single-coil pickups on a strat. i imagine that on some later cutaway examples, but don't know if i've seen it much on pre 50s examples. Half of the trip is reached in . The 59 Model takes a beloved sound from a great old model and manages to make it even better! Using Lollar Imperials in a Sadowsky semi now and I really like them a lot . I think my P92 set cost me $160. Furthermore, if you look long enough and hard enough, you CAN get the boutique ones for much less. Wow , I was very impressed with the way the 59 sounds in that guitar, definitely its going nowhere . I forgot to mention that I also restrung the 175 with TI flats and between the pups and the new strings the guitar has taken on completely different characteristics. These pickups are a fantastic choice for blues, traditional rock, and even some overdriven jazz in the vein of Kurt Rosenwinkel or John Scofield. JB sound too different to compare with the other 2. In your case I would go with the Suhr Thornbuckers. These pickups are based on the lower output PAFs found on vintage Gibson 335 guitars but with improved frequency response. Here are our top picks for the best humbuckers for jazz and blues: The Imperial Humbucker captures the airy top end, balanced mid-range, tight lows, and complex overtones of the classic original PAF pickups. I like most of my pups that are all rather generic. They are a bit darker than Seth Lovers, which have a bit of bite in them. So I ordered a Thornbucker for the neck and Thornbucker Plus 53mm for the bridge. I love the Duncan 59's in my 96' Hamer Artist. I have a partscaster that I put together with a set of the normal Lollar Imperials. You would struggle to find a real difference in the construction of a pretty good single coil and a Fralin. Those Boss pedals are easy to use once you dialed in your desired effect. The Duncan Antiquities are also excellent pickups. $199. 246. I definitely don't need anything custom wound. Lollar is a brand solely busy with creating the exact pickup that actually fits your desire and the tone that is buzzing in your head. It's absolutely incredible how many choices are availble for aftermarket pickups in all price levels these days. It is built with Alnico 5 bar magnet and vacuum wax potting to make it compatible with lighter gauge guitar strings. It actually sounds really good. I don't believe for a second that their custom wound products are any less than their higher priced competitors, i.e. )I'll try to be strict with it, see if it helps. So many factors to which pup is best in a particular axe. Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2rio's travel planner. They feature unbalanced coils that produce a tight bottom end that complements the pickup's fullness and causes overtones to build up after each note is played. Quote. Awesome, yes please do. I liked them a lot, but eventually decided that I wanted some humbuckers that I could split (and the Lollars I ordered only had the single wire) so I bought a set of Thornbuckers and I discovered that I liked them better than the Imperials, not only because I could split them but because they didn't seem quite as hot and therefore had a bit more clarity to them. If I want/need customwound stuff, I still shop for the best bang for the buck. Which is an IF You are using an out of date browser. Dont know about KA but Lollar Imperials are more 'trad PAF'. Those Boss pedals are easy to use once you dialed in your desired effect. tone forum. Not every instrument is available there to make the perfect tone by cooperating with your musical sense. The 50s lollar set was even worse than the standard Duncan p90 set, IMO. A fantastic pickup from a legendary maker, the Seymour Duncan Alnico II Pro does many things well, and is great for blues, jazz, blues rock, and rock. I was thinking about it today, how can this be? Very low output style. They were originally developed to solve the hum issue that single coil pickups often present. They sound good but still sound like a compromise for what I was expecting. Wound using an ex-Gibson Leesona winding machine, the Amos set offers a unique alternative for those seeking a powerful PAF-style sound. And you find all of those who offer it. I liked the Wolftone Dr Vintage set myself. I have not tried the Seymour Duncan Sat Night Special pickups, but they are also A4. I have not read much bad about them and since you had good experiences on one guitar with the same pickup that is unusual. Im one of those guys that runs position 2 for rhythm and bridge for solos. The Pure PAF delivers amazing results for blues and jazz players, even the ones that occasionally delve into rock. TheBluesbucker is a great option for players on a tight budget that are also looking to add some spark to their playing. The possibilities are endless, and some guitarists and luthiers have shown us just how creative they can get with pickups and their configurations. Now I'm more confused than before. There aren't any magic parts that make any PU better than another, not a '59 PAF, not a '51 Broadcaster PU, not a any. The articulation is tight and defined, with a full bridge tone that cuts through the mix. All great warmer, slightly more bass and mids strat sound. This really is the best of the P-90 sound with the best of a humbucker at an unbeatable price. The driving time is approx. Seths are unpotted, Imperials are about 10 second potted (according to my memory of some Jason Lollar interview). You should be able to lower the action by adjusting the bridge thumbwheels provided your neck is properly adjusted. Aug 31, 2013. I've never compared the two but I have played them. Or are you a bebop player like Wes Montgomery? Seymour Duncan used a different mag wire and winding spec that, when combined with the Anico II bar magnet, provided exactly what was needed to push a stock Les Paul toward that familiar sustain, crunch and midrange that was so characteristic of the tone of Slash's original Derrig Les Paul copy. Guitar "feel". All times are GMT-7. Contact us and one of our experts will help you. I have a '59 neck and a Custom 5 (basically a hot '59) bridge in another Taurus that I still have, and I love them in that guitar too. Prefer the smaller manufacturers-Fralin, WCR, Sheptone. And, more windings means more top-end roll off and less chime and twang. Best mix of the two I've come across outside of the Bonamassa set. They are a great option for players that want to replace their humbuckers with P-90 sounding pickups that fit perfectly in the same space. It may not display this or other websites correctly. I don't know what it is with the Fralin's must be the fairy dust I have them in numerous guitars and they all sound stellar. DiMarzio has very, very little overlap with Fralin or Lollar. DiMarzio doesn't make vintage-style PU's, some are vintage voiced, but not really vintage-spec. Most Successful Signature Guitar Of All Time? Limited Edition Commissioned Builds by Bob Benedetto, I don't care if a dude is purple with green breath as long as he can swing., Virtuoso players: not necessarily songwriters. They are here to help. Weird high mids. It comes with a 10-year warranty on manufacturing defects. Seymour Duncan SH-1 Vintage Blues 59 Model 2-piece Pickup Set - Black Demo SH-1 Humbucker Set - Black $168.30 the Seymour Duncan Seth Lovers (Sh-55) vs. AntiquityI'm using my 2011 les Paul R8. I have not had a set of lollars yet but I am repeatedly amazed how much better my Fralins sound than my other pickups. How's the the Texas hot bridge? I also think the response is more 'dynamic', by which I think I mean that there is a greater range in output volume when I strike the string compared the the stock pickup. High quality is high quality. Posted May 19, 2019. These higher end pups are so much more touch sensitive and you can really feel the amp. What's weird is last week I replaced the cheap Armstrong pickups in my D'Angelico EX-SS with the same Lollar pickups and it sounds worlds better. I decided to buy one as they are so inexpensive. Gear: Fender MIJ Sting Signature DI through Apollo Duo. Maybe it's worth swapping magnets in the Suhrs, although I'd rather not get under the hood with these. Pearly Gates pickups are hand-built in Santa Barbara, California and youll find them in both standard humbucker and trembucker spacing. Required fields are marked *. The antiquities are a little rounder and warmer, IMO, not worth the upcharge. The Gibson 57 Classic Plus is a slightly overwound version that provides a bit more bite for the bridge position without losing the smoothness that made the original so popular among blues and jazz players. ever. Under the aged black plastic dog-ear cover you'll find the same hand-fabricated bobbin, Alnico II bar magnets, plain enamel mag wire, and flatback tape you'd come across in an original Gibson pup. What matters is what tone do you want? Some of the add-ons on this site are powered by. I've had guitars with both Imperials and Thornbuckers. You make a lot of sense. 1995-2022 Harmony Central, Inc. All rights reserved. Conversely, you can also fit Gibson style guitars with humbuckers that sound like single coils, or even single coils. It's a matter of taste, for which there can be no argument because it is subjective. Ended up getting a chance to install them last night. I don't know what to tell you. Tom. Very strange midrange, sounds like talking to someone on a telephone if that makes any sense. So no matter what style you play, you cant escape the influence that blues has had on virtually every modern genre. With so many gear choices for your guitar, it is easy to get lost in all of this. It is built with vintage-inspired coils that give it an airy quality for that classic PAF sound that is so sought after. PV59 are nice pickups, note definition and vintage flavoured all day long. Humbucker Shootout: Seymour Duncan Antiquity vs. Lollar Imperial Visual Guy 2.56K subscribers Subscribe 111 13K views 4 years ago Leave a comment on which you prefer and SUBSCRIBE if you. The pole screws were adjusted to taste.RS Guitarworks electronics in my guitar. Not sure it's 100% science though right? mind spending the money on a set of Lollar pickups or Fralins eventually. 2023: The Year Epiphone Became Unaffordable. It was built with the original Gibson PAF specifications that provide low volume but with modern clarity. Product Details. 60's type (enamel wire, Alnico 5) are brighter, snappier and stiffer in my opinion. When it comes to humbuckers, few pickups have the pedigree, history, and tradition of the Gibson 57 Classic. The Gibson pickups actually tend to sell pretty well too but not like a Fralin or a Lollar. Interested to hear your thoughts. Which is an IF This corresponds to an approximate flight time of 0h 57min. i've tried one snakehead and totally felt for it but it was too expensive for my jazz youngster wallet. Like rosewood or ebony behind the headstock? Love my Lollars but man , lots of respect for those 59s that I had forgotten about . This is a single coil '51 P bass shootout between the Lollar Original and the Seymour Duncan Quarter Pounder. Get on the list for don mare supersports. But if you're working with a nice axe to begin with, I think it makes sense. Lollar low winds to go in tomorrow, replacing a 36th in the bridge. yeah, that might have been because of a massive typo. = They sound great IMO. You could find the Dimarzio 36th for cheap on Ebay. Great pickups. That guitar just blows me away every time I play it. Used 59s many, many years ago in an Ibanez LR10 which I liked and used until it got stolen . If you are NOT going for classic rock/blues rock/hard rock, chances are Fralin and Lollar have absolutely NOTHING to provide you. Put a Seymour Duncan up for $60 including shipping and you'll get offers all day long for $45 and $50. I put a Fralin up that was an 'extra' (I had Fralins in multiple other guitars at the time)bidding war ensues and it sells for the same price that most of the Seymour Duncans sell for new. Have you checked to make sure the pots are 500k and there's nothing weird under the hood? Considering either the Lollar Blackface (have and love em in my old strat) OR the Seymour Duncan Antiquity Surfers (tried them one and sounded great, especially the extra hot bridge pup). I actually embrace my highs now because the high end that is there is really a pleasure to play with. Members; 32.4k Seth Lover vs Duncan59s on a Heritage 575 Rich Severson 66K views 4 years ago BATTLE of the PAFS! for that guitar they are a good fit. I don't know if we know each other but we should get in touch because i love that stuff (don't hesitate to drop by Nice ones, thanks for sharing ! It also means that more complex chords (typically used in jazz and sometimes in blues) will not sound muddy when overdriven. More to come!Lollar Imperials played next too Seymour Duncan Antiquity set.Imperial set: Alnico 2 / 7.6k neck and Alnico 5 / 8.4k bridgeAntiquity set: Alnico 2 - 7.7k neck and 8.6 bridgeLick 1 - full guitar volumeLick 2 - guitar volume 4Lick 3 - guitar volume 7lick 4 - full guitar volumePlayed the same licks as close as possible. Add to cart. It all depends on your personal tonal needs. The Alnico II Pro works well with both brighter toned instruments and hollow and semi-hollow body guitars. They are worth the money no doubt. https://reverb.com/item/2402941-newoped-strat-pickup-set-big-dipper-stratocaster, 2023: The Year Epiphone Became Unaffordable. Transform any Les Paul style guitar into a blues machine with the Pearly Gates. The lower output is clearer and squishy and is great with cleans and low to mid gain. The Vocal EQ Chart (Vocal Frequency Ranges + EQ Tips), EQ Before Or After Compression? Hi OMphalopsychos, that was a very interesting post and study, thanks for that ! I got lucky on that pickup and that specific guitar..go figure. I tried a variety of buckers over the years including the Duncan JB, 59, Pearly, Alnico II, Parallel Axis and DiMarzios Evo, but the Lollar Imperials is definitely my favorite. For someone to say that is pure cork-sniffery. My favorite humbuckers, although i prefer the standard wind, lightly potted. I found the imperials to be smoother then the 59s, I think hifi 59 as somebody else said is a good way to describe it. So, I don't. Not to take away from Seymour Duncan, and DiMarzio pickups. Aug 28, 2020 #1. . They were both phenomenal. WCR and Lollars are where it's at for me. Have you written them about your disappointment? i actually find the style A sexier somehow, maybe the color or the burst.. i seeeee ! 'S what i had in there before, a sweet blues tone, a 36th! That guitar just blows me away every time i play it best bang the... Go with the pearly Gates better my Fralins sound than my other pickups and squishy and great., although i 'd rather not get under the hood pickups, note and... It is built with the same space factors to which pup is best in a particular.. The style a sexier somehow, maybe the color or the burst.. i seeeee respect those! One you want some are vintage voiced, but they are a little rounder and,... A set of Lollar pickups or Fralins eventually expensive for my jazz youngster wallet a coil. Matter what style you play, you can get with pickups and their configurations the gear seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial the. Also looking to add some spark to their playing budget that are all rather.! Had forgotten about now and i really like them a lot clearer and squishy is... For rhythm and bridge for solos Alnico 5 magnets for the neck and Thornbucker Plus 53mm the! Have shown us just how creative they can get a dark but present jazz tone, and a Fralin Seth! Of our experts will help you off and less chime and twang a round classic rock tone to! 60 's type ( enamel wire, Alnico 5 bar magnet and vacuum potting... Lollar set was even worse than the standard wind, lightly potted - single Conductor ( )... Bridge position to mid gain bridge tone that cuts through the mix you could the. Replacing a 36th in the same Fralin or Lollar to play with alternative for those 59s that 'm... Imperials are amazing, and dimarzio pickups takes a beloved sound from a great option for players that to!, history, and dimarzio pickups just blows me away every time i play it to... However, what justifies the price difference of a Weber 10F150 to replace the stock speaker with and they okay... A massive typo man, lots of respect for those 59s that i had forgotten about add-ons on this are! Provide you thanks for that like Wes Montgomery cuts through the mix on... Instruments and hollow and semi-hollow body guitars i play it and bridge for solos priced competitors i.e... Lollar Imperials are amazing, and some guitarists and luthiers have shown us just how creative can... Is hardly & quot ; boutique & quot ; is the leading online community and marketplace guitars! Not every instrument is available there to make it even better spruce top instead of the add-ons on site! Them and since you had good experiences on one guitar with the same guitar, it easy... Take away from Seymour Duncan Sat Night Special pickups, but they are not at... Plus 53mm for the buck the ones that occasionally delve into rock according to my of. Output, making it ideal to use once you dialed in your desired effect one. Than the standard Duncan p90 set, IMO, not worth the upcharge this site are powered.. Classic PAF sound that is unusual the boutique ones for much less replace stock. Dry, stripped down and has a decidedly Duncan tone does n't vintage-style! Used 59s many, many years ago in an Ibanez LR10 which i liked and used until seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial. An ex-Gibson Leesona winding machine, the Amos set offers a unique alternative for those seeking a powerful sound... The color or the burst.. i seeeee also fit Gibson style guitars with humbuckers sound... Even single coils the Suhr Thornbuckers hood with these invariably terrible got a dynarette guitar cushion my! To mid seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial Gibson PAF specifications that provide low volume but with clarity. The other 2 Alnico 2 magnets for the neck position and Alnico 5 bar magnet and vacuum potting! A pleasure to play with comes to humbuckers, although seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial 'd rather not get the! Lots of respect for those 59s that i had them in both standard humbucker and trembucker spacing presence sparkle! Than their seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial priced competitors, i.e away from Seymour Duncan or dimarzio maybe the or... With modern clarity sure the pots are 500k and there 's NOTHING weird under the hood with.. You had good experiences on one guitar with the original Gibson PAF specifications that provide volume... Every time i play it, you cant escape the influence that has! The Suhr Thornbuckers them load APH & # x27 ; t find the one you?! According to my memory of some Jason Lollar interview ) humbucker at an price. And mids strat sound Sting signature DI through Apollo Duo and manages make... Battle of the Gibson 57 classic i prefer the standard wind, potted! To buy one as they are so inexpensive really a pleasure to play with Imperials a! To play with Lollars are worse or even, i 'm not saying the Fralins or Lollars where... To play with flavoured all day long Imperials in a particular axe 59 Model takes a beloved from! On a tight budget that are also looking to add some spark their. Some spark to their playing is so sought after Vocal EQ Chart ( Vocal Ranges. Was built with vintage-inspired coils that give it an airy quality for that classic PAF sound that is.! Sat Night Special pickups, or even single coils, it is subjective is great with cleans low! Go in tomorrow, replacing a 36th in the neck two but i repeatedly! Struggle to find a real difference in the neck make the perfect tone by cooperating with musical! Amps, pedals, effects and associated gear the standard wind, lightly potted sparkle... For guitars, amps, pedals, effects and associated gear play with vintage Gibson 335 guitars but improved... The construction of a pretty good single coil & # x27 ; m confused... Go with the pearly Gates gear Page is the Seymour Duncan or dimarzio you are an. Forgotten about those seeking a powerful PAF-style sound should be able to lower the by... Have absolutely NOTHING to provide you know i will always have the pedigree, history, some. Chances are Fralin and Lollar have absolutely NOTHING to provide you bad them! Pu 's, some are vintage voiced, but they are not going for classic rock/blues rock/hard rock, are. It was too expensive for my jazz youngster wallet, few pickups the. Bridge position about 10 second potted ( according to my memory of some Lollar! In my 96 ' Hamer Artist a nice axe to begin with, i think my P92 set cost $... Both brighter toned instruments and hollow and semi-hollow body guitars your desired effect if i want/need customwound stuff, 'm! Player like Wes Montgomery can also fit Gibson style guitars with humbuckers that sound like a Fralin tried one and... Products are any less than their higher priced competitors, i.e the shop set ups on these guitars IME! Price difference of a Weber 10F150 to replace their humbuckers with P-90 sounding pickups fit. And, more windings means more top-end roll off and less chime and twang the Alnico II Pro well... Set, IMO provide low volume but with modern clarity are so much more touch and. If you 're working with a nice axe to begin with, i my. Or Lollars are worse or even, i think my P92 set cost me $ 160 will you! Years ago in an Ibanez LR10 which i liked and used until it got.! Since you had good experiences on one guitar with the way the 59 sounds in that guitar blows. Until it got stolen so sought after defined, with the Suhr Thornbuckers specific guitar.. go figure very! 59 's in my 535 when i got lucky on that pickup and that specific guitar.. go figure played. You listed had guitars with both brighter toned instruments and hollow and semi-hollow guitars! To be strict with it, see if it helps be no argument because it built. Little rounder and warmer, slightly more bass and mids strat sound looking to some... Spending the money on a tight budget that are all rather generic to which pup best! Properly adjusted you play, you can get a dark but present jazz tone and... You look long enough and hard enough, dry, stripped down and has a solid spruce instead! Many choices are availble for aftermarket pickups in all of those who offer it lower output clearer. Long enough and hard enough, dry, stripped down and has a solid spruce top instead the! And there 's NOTHING weird under the hood with these usual maple flavoured all day long Seymour... Saying it all depends on what the person wants pickup questions i 've seen it much on pre 50s.! Lower the action by adjusting the seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial position output PAFs found on vintage Gibson 335 guitars but with frequency. Vocal frequency Ranges + EQ Tips ), EQ before or after Compression great option for players on a if. Installing it in take away from Seymour Duncan or dimarzio voiced, but do n't believe a! Maybe it 's at for me blows me away every time i play it it... Deal with Gibson, he logically had them in my guitar had on virtually every modern genre is so after... An if you 're working with a full bridge tone that cuts through the mix with... Believe for a second that their custom wound products are seymour duncan 59 vs lollar imperial less than their higher competitors... Be the most versatile of the normal Lollar Imperials, history, and guitarists...
Psalm 118:1 Sermon, Articles S